An Analysis of the 2026 US General Election

Anthony Mansueto

The 2026 US General Election represented an extraordinary and in many ways unprecedented repudiation of Donald Trump, of his “Make America Great Again” movement, and of the Republican Party, and showed renewed strength in the capacity of the Democratic Party to frame public discourse in a way which creates strong electoral majorities for a politics focused on the Common Good, present a broad range of compelling candidates across a diverse political spectrum without losing coherence, manage the fall-out from errors, and turn out voters in record numbers.

Our victory this November represents a significant step in reversing the tide of Fascism in the United States and globally and in engaging humanity in facing together the critical challenges facing our planet and our civilizations. With this in mind we need to understand exactly what happened and why in order to map our our next steps in what will be the two very critical years ahead, as well as in the longue duree.

What Happened?

The basic election results are as follows:

Democrats captured roughly 56% of the vote, Republicans 46%
Democrats took control of both houses of Congress, and will hold at least 55 seats in the Senate, including independents who caucus with them, and at least 255 seats in the House of Representatives.
Democrats won 22 Gubernatorial races and how control 28 out of 50 governorships. In many historically Republican states, such as Texas, Democrats swept all statewide races and flipped at least one house of the state legislature.

The results were all the more remarkable, however, because while Democrats certainly did well in Great Lakes states such as Wisconsin, Michigan,  Ohio, and Pennsylvania where they have struggled in recent elections, they did even better in the Atlantic South, which is now being called a new “Blue Wall.”

Essentially every demographic group shifted towards the Democrats, but some did so more profoundly than others. The biggest shift was among two key groups where Democrats were weaker than they should have been in 2024: the youngest voters, especially young men, and  Latino voters. Voters under 30 shifted Democratic by 32 points, and men under 30 shifted Democratic by 38 points. Similarly, Latino voters overall shifted Democratic by 28 points, while Latino men under 30 shifted Democratic by 47 points.  We don’t have any strong evidence post election, but late polls showed that 62% of Latino Evangelicals, about two thirds of whom supported Trump in 2024, now see him as a dangerous dictator.  Other groups with more than the overall/average shift towards Democrats of 15% include Asians (25 points), all “other races,” i.e. ethnic groups other than European origin, African American, Latino, or Asian (24 points), urban and suburban voters (19 and 20 points respectively), voters 30-44 (18 points) and Catholic voters (16 points).

This said, while analyzing partisan shifts is critical to understanding what has changed since the last election, if we ask who drove the Democratic victory, it would be a crime not to acknowledge the leading role of the African American community and especially the role of African American women, who now stand clearly and without any real competition in the forefront of the antifascist struggle and the broader struggle to hold the United States accountable to its own founding principles. Having won key races all around the country, but especially in Texas and parts of the Deep South, African American women will be setting the agenda for the coming period in the United States.

What Led to Such Large Partisan Shifts Among Key Demographics?

The reasons behind the Democratic victory are not difficult to understand, and if we were surprised, especially by the scope of the victory, it is only because after 2024 we have come to expect electoral sabotage, especially electronic sabotage, of the kind to which Elon Musk has effectively confessed. Still those reasons are complex and layered, it is worth excavating them carefully.

There are two principal reasons for the massive partisan shift which took place over the course of this past election cycle. The first concerns what Trump and the Republican Party have done wrong. The second concerns what the Democratic Party has done right.

A Treasonous Politics of Grand Strategic Destruction and Sabotage

The people of the United States  repudiated Trump, MAGA, and the Republican Party not because he failed to deliver on his promise to “Make America Great Again,” but because he succeeded so brilliantly in doing exactly what he was actually trying to do: i.e. to damage the United States in every way that he possibly could. This may seem like an outrageous accusation, but I intend it quite literally. The damage Trump has done to the US economy, to the US state apparatus, and to key cultural institutions including universities and the press, is not the product of an incorrect understanding of what is best for the country, but is, rather, an act of intentional destruction and sabotage on the part of the Russian State and the Dark Enlightenment.

This claim requires some context. Let us consider the case of Russia first. Russia is and always has been in a geopolitically disadvantageous position from which it has found no true escape. The  Russian core is too far north to support agriculture of the kind which would guarantee food self-sufficiency, and lacks the river networks which made most civilizational centers viable. It is vulnerable to invasion from the West across the essentially flat North Eurasian Plain and from the East across the steppes of Central Asia  –something which has happened multiple times in the past. And whatever the current appearance of alliance with China, Russia is vulnerable from the southeast as well. What Russia does have, in addition to significant petroleum and other mineral reserves, is a complex, highly inflected language, which makes it much easier for native Russian speakers to become fluent in other Indo-European languages than it is for speakers of those languages to become fluent in Russian.

A handful of Russian leaders –Peter the Great, Catherine the Great, and the Communist Party leadership up through the 1970s– attempted to create new comparative advantages in the hope of strengthening Russia as a civilization and as a Great Power.  The development of a rationalized, centralized bureaucracy in which the nobility was compelled to serve, together with significant investment in the arts and humanities, the sciences –social as well as physical and biological– and in technology, especially in its military applications, strengthened Russia considerably, and the Russian Revolution allowed a massive rationalization of the way in which the surplus extracted from the peasantry was invested, though only at the cost of famine and mass starvation. Ultimately, though, most of these gains were spent on the battlefield during two World Wars and the Cold War, leaving much of Russia still largely underdeveloped even as it boasted one of the world’s premier academic, scientific, and cultural establishments, and was likely the world leader in key fields including mathematics, materials science, and space exploration.  And when the Soviet Union collapsed, most of these gains were lost as the state enterprises were privatized into the hands of organized crime and the intelligence services.

This left the Russian Federation a weak state, certainly by comparison with its aspirations, positioned in the global economy as an oil and gas and to a lesser estent a mineral exporter, with a nuclear stockpile which is of limited use unless it wishes to risk planetary annihilation  –but also one of the planet’s most highly developed intelligence apparatuses, built on the foundation of the highly inflected grammar of the Russian language and a legacy of Leninist strategic foresight, organizing prowess, and massive investments in the humanities and social sciences.  And this has dictated the grand strategy of the Russian state: sowing chaos and destruction among its principal rival states, trying to destroy or at least cripple those with whom it cannot hope to compete.  

Russia has been grooming Trump for decades. The KGB undoubtedly originally saw him as a “useful idiot” who they could use to compromise one or another US political leader and/or to assist with money laundering or other minor operations. He has, of course, turned out to be worth much, much more. Since he was activated over a decade ago, he has done far more than any Russian leader ever imagined possible, if not always reliably and intelligently, to implement the grand strategy of the Kremlin. Nearly everything Trump has done —mass deportations of immigrant workers essential to the US economy, the systematic destruction of large parts of the federally funded research apparatus, killing tariffs on imports in an economy optimized over the past 40 years for free trade, the purging of the senior military leadership, attacks on universities, a catastrophic war which revealed the actual limits of US military strength, state sponsored violence on the streets and in our homes, most of it racially targeted but just enough of it seemingly random to terrorize everyone– has been directed at weakening the economic, political, and cultural capacity of the United States in service to Vladimir Putin’s project of Russian imperial restoration.

The second force behind the economic and more especially the institutional destruction of the past two years is the Dark Enlightenment. The Dark Enlightenment, we will recall, is the political and ideological expression of the high technology oligarchs who have emerged out of the bourgeoisie in recent years but who seem to be developing into a new social class of their own, aiming to liberate themselves from not only democratic and regulatory constraints but also from market forces, establishing what some have called a techno-feudal state. The Dark Enlightenment envisions a future in which the existing political order is destroyed and political authority is privatized into the hands of oligarchs who, in addition to everything else, run their own cities which people can leave, but within which they have no voice. The long term aim of the group seems to be the displacement of most or all of humanity with Artificial Intelligence, the execution of grand technological projects such as the colonization of Mars (almost certainly centuries away), and ultimately the realization of the technocratic secular ideal of transcending finitude by means of scientific, technological, and economic progress.

This was the motivation behind DOGE, which was a sloppy implementation of Curtis Yarvin’s RAGE (Retire All Government Employees Now) proposal. And of course key elements of this operation, such as the destruction of USAID, by destroying US soft power, also advanced the Russian agenda.

Even Trump, of course, could not have convinced the people of the United States to simply destroy their own country. Thus the need for MAGA and the mobilization of racist and misogynist ideology, already present in the country, to legitimate his policies. This is the sense in which Trump’s regime is Fascist. Historic fascism leveraged racist and misogynist ideology in order to mobilize and militarize the population in support of a politics of imperialist expansion and restoration. MAGA leverages racist and misogynist ideology in order to mobilize popular support for the destruction of civil society and state institutions which stand in the way of Russian imperial restoration and the Dark Enlightenment vision of a humanity displaced or augmented by Artificial Intelligence and ultimately transcending finitude by technological means.

With this in mind we should note that the only thing which has really been built in the past several years is Generative Artificial Intelligence –along with the massive, ecologically damaging data centers which it requires. Artificial Intelligence has emerged as a central political issue, and it is weighing, at least for now, heavily against the Republicans. Generative AI itself has both threatened the liquidation of much of the intelligentsia, technical and business as well as artistic and humanistic, and sparked sharp resistance from the academy and religious institutions, led by Pope Leo XIV. And just as the midterm election campaign was peaking, clusters of local struggles emerged across the country, including many in Republican territory, over attempts to rush in permits to build data centers.  

That the majority of people in the United States were able to awaken from the madness of the past two years and reject this chaos and destruction is an indication that the institutional destruction and demoralization of US society, while advanced, has not reached a point of no return.  As a (very rough) measure of this, we can point to the fact that only 24% of the US population considers themselves MAGA, only somewhat more than consider themselves democratic socialists (18%). At the same time, we do need to take into account that this is actually the highest percentage since September 2022, since when it has been increasing from 11% to its present level.

What this means is that Republican voters who do not see themselves as MAGA (including Independents and historic Democrats who have voted for Trump in the past) have withdrawn their support from Trump and from the Republican Party, as a result of the destruction Trump has caused. Even more clearly, groups which swung to Trump in 2024 have now swung away sharply, especially Latino Evangelicals and young men.

Finally, while it would be a mistake to say that there was no attempt on the part of the Right to steal the election, any such attempt was ineffective and not highly visible. This we attribute to direct countermeasures and broader organizing on the part of the Democratic Party, which either blocked such efforts or made them seem less likely to be worth the risk.

The Party of Humanity and of Hope

The second reason for the  Democratic victory was the incredible strength of both the underlying organization of the Democratic Party and its ability to deploy that strength operationally and tactically over the course of this last election cycle. The Democratic Party, despite significant internal differences, was able to:

frame the election as a debate about Trump and his most destructive policies, with an emphasis on the higher prices and global instability which have resulted from the war, the killing increases in health care premiums as a result of the effective gutting of the ACA, the rise of Generative Artificial Intelligence, and the raw, brutal violence against women and historically oppressed communities at home, 
present a clear, broadly unified but not monolithic critique of the Trump regime and the Republican Party and an alternative vision centered on a return to economic sanity and human decency –in effect to rebuilding the country after what has amounted to a proxy war fought against us –by our own government– on behalf of Russia and the Dark Enlightenment, and 
run a sufficiently effective ground game to capitalize on these strengths on election day.  

These operational and tactical strengths were, however, rooted in decades of ongoing strategic work on the part of organizers in trade unions, local communities and congregations, and a range of other organizations, especially in the places where we saw surprising victories –the Atlantic South, pockets in the Interior Deep South, and in Texas, Kansas, and Iowa (as well as in the many places we didn’t win but made progress). While most of the publicity about the “Left” wing of the Democratic Party has gone to “democratic socialists” who target other progressive Democrats (often African American women), fixate on single issues and, in fact, single, often poorly thought out demands (Medicare for All, the Destruction of Israel), and charge everyone who disagrees with them with complicity in the Gaza Genocide, there is another Left entirely, much of it African American, Latino, or Asian, which has been working tirelessly and invisibly in communities around the country, including especially in the Deep South, Texas, and elsewhere for forty years or more, building relationships with people, listening to them, and helping them to articulate and act on their aspirations for a truly human life. These organizers do, for the most part, aspire to much more for the United States and for humanity than just a return to the status quo ante and a slightly better social safety net. They are just working for those more ambitious aims quietly and organically with and through the people for whom that future will represent the greatest liberation, rather than with threats and flashy slogans and attempts to undermine their closest allies.

They, and the people they are organizing, are the foundation of our future.

What Next?

Given this analysis, what are our principal tasks in the coming period? Here we need to consider both the electoral level, and the level of deep organizing which makes effective electoral work possible.

At the level of the next and future electoral cycles we need to build on the extraordinary success of the Democratic Party. There are two principal aspects to this task. First, as we have said, the Democratic Party did a very good job in this cycle of framing the election in way which took advantage of the conjuncture, focusing attention on Trump’s most destructive policies. We need to build on this success and cultivate a party leadership which does this consistently, even as the situation changes. This means that the party must craft a realistic legislative agenda which produces real progress towards recovery from the damage Trump has done –or else makes it absolutely clear to the people that the Republican Party is standing in the way of that recovery. And it means creating fora for dialogue and deliberation between different factions in the party regarding both that agenda and the way we frame future electoral struggles. The progressive/centrist working groups which Hakim Jeffries has suggested represent a significant step in this direction.

At the same time, we have to be clear that our role in shaping the dynamics of the struggle is limited. We cannot simply decide what we want the next election to be about. That will be the product of decisions by many different actors across the country and around world. What we need to do is to be clear on how the struggle is being framed, and position ourselves to take advantage of each new configuration of forces as it presents itself. And we need to work very hard to help elements of the party which want the next election to be about their highest priority, whether it is Medicare for All or Gaza or something we haven’t yet thought of, that this approach simply will not work. And we need to be clear that those who insist on this sort of framing are at best spoilers and at worst Putinist or other Rightist operatives.

Our ability to position the party in this way across different electoral cycles as the underlying political terrain shifts will be strengthened if we can cultivate a clear identity for the party. This is always difficult in the United States, where parties have not historically been defined by class or ideology, but rather as alliances based on ethnoreligious identity and regional interests. Historically, the Republicans represented groups closest to the Puritan core of the New England founding, as it had been transformed by way of the First and Second Great Awakenings. This meant essentially all English origin North Americans in New England and the Middle Atlantic, including Unitarians, Congregationalists, Presbyterians, and Methodists, with Episcopalians more nearly split, and Presbyterians and Methodists less Republican the further one got from the coasts.  Republicans also consolidated support among less confessional and liturgical German Lutherans, and among Norwegian, Swedish, and Finnish Lutherans generally, along with most Nordic sectarian and pietistic groups. After the Civil War, African Americans were, for obvious reasons, overwhelmingly Republican.

The Democrats were, on the other hand, a party of outsiders from this Puritan core, and included most Catholics, though French Canadian Catholics split, most confessional and liturgical German Lutherans and Reformed, and Southern Episcopalian, Methodists, Presbyterians, and Baptists. Jews have been and remain historically Democratic.

To the extent that “issues” divided the parties, the key divisions were around Slavery and Reconstruction, Tariffs, and Temperance and Prohibition, with Republicans more likely to be anti-slavery and pro-Reconstruction (though not with any great consistency or conviction), pro-tariff, and in favor of Temperance and Prohibition, and Democrats generally soft on slavery and racism generally, for free trade, and against prohibition.

Obviously, what it means to be a “Heritage American,” as MAGA likes to put it, has changed in response to critical conjunctures such as the Great Depression and New Deal, the Civil Rights Movement, and the “new social movements” of the 1960s and later, but the basic principle behind the divisions has remained. The Democrats, embracing immigrants, African Americans, women, those who challenge gender norms, and those who support cosmopolitanism generally, are the party of “outsiders,” while Republicans are increasingly the party of White Identity and Christian Patriarchal Nationalism. Those religious communities closest to the original English elites, interestingly enough –Unitarians, Congregationalists, and Episcopalians especially, and Presbyterians and Methodists to a very significant extent– have shifted their allegiance to the Democrats, largely because their historic commitment to liberal rights inclined them to support pluralism even as they (and their more secularized children) remain culturally aloof.

How can this outsider identity be transformed in to a clear, positive, meaningful statement of principles and values which is still broad enough to embrace the whole Democratic electorate and susceptible of being fine-tuned to the current conjuncture? Democrats are the party of humanity, as against the hegemony of any one nation or nationality, and as against the Dark Enlightenment vision of a future in which humanity is increasingly displaced by Artificial Intelligence, and MAGA, which would exclude from full citizenship the vast majority of our people. We are the party of pluralism, respecting the right of everyone to decide for themselves what it means to be human, as long as it is not harmful to others, even if we do not understand or embrace that way ourselves.  We are the party of care, compassion, and empathy against the Dark Enlightenment which teaches that empathy is humanity’s greatest weakness. And –recognizing that contradictions are inevitable and that people really do sometimes have competing interests– we are the party of rule of law as against privilege and dictatorship. Internally we respect differences regarding what these principles mean, and differences in social analysis regarding not just particular policy proposals but also fundamental structural questions, such as whether or not and to what degree capitalism is compatible with our values, the nature of racism and gender oppression. We are a Big Tent which nevertheless knows where we stand.

While most pundits remain focused on the contradiction between “Centrist” or “mainstream” Democrats and “Progressives” or “Democratic Socialists,” I would like to suggest that the more challenging cleavage is going to be between those who have become heavily invested in Artificial Intelligence over the past several years, and who may be reluctant to regulate it, fearing the impact on their stock portfolios and 401k’s, and those for whom resistance to Artificial Intelligence is emerging as a defining issue. More broadly, we will need to see how much of the liberal bourgeoisie, which has remained mostly loyal to the Democratic Party, is willing to accept income transfers of the sort we saw during the early stages of the Pandemic, which begin to relieve market pressures on the petty bourgeoisie and working classes, and the elimination of which cost the party dearly.

Second, we need to build on both the party’s effective ground game in this election and the much longer term, much deeper organizing which has been going on in parts of the country for decades, to build an authentic party organization. Our aim, over the long haul, should be to have a national precinct organization with a precinct captain in every precinct and block captains on every block who are engaged in regular conversations with their neighbors, who have relationships with them which go beyond existing party alignments, which are based on understanding who they are and what they are trying to accomplish in life, and on helping them move forward towards their goals, cutting red tape, connecting them with resources, etc. We are a very long way from this, and I know that some people will argue that such a territorial approach is passe. I will leave that debate until next time. What we can do over the next four years is to make a start, connecting party electoral organizers with organizers and leaders across sectors to begin negotiating a relationship between electoral, community, and labor struggles, and to lay down the bare bones of the sort of national precinct organization I have described.  

This said, readers of Seeking Wisdom will already know that I do not believe that electoral politics supported by trade union and community struggles are sufficient. And my own positions on the need to transcend capitalism and to get at the root of racism and gender oppression are clear.  How do we move forward towards a more profound realization of the values we have outlined above, understanding that this means transcending capitalism, racism, and gender oppression?

Here is our starting point, and where we differ from most communists and especially from our very overconfident democratic socialist colleagues, in acknowledging that 1) we don’t know how to transcend capitalism and 2) we do understand the critical importance of institutions which form people intellectually and morally in service to the Common Good.

Let us consider each of these points in turn. Historic socialism, while it produced some important social advances, lifting billions out of poverty, did not do the trick. Here it is important to understand that authentic communism, as opposed to socialism, which has always been intended as merely a transitional form, involves decommodifying labor power. This is because so long as the majority of people are forced to sell their labor power in order to survive, such axial and liberal freedoms as the right to decide for ourselves what it means to be human and to live accordingly are meaningless. Nationalizing industry, or having the state displace capital markets as the principal allocator of resources for production, did not lead naturally to the decommodification of labor power. It simply allowed primitive accumulation in colonized countries or in marginalized empires, such as  Russia or China where the surplus extracted from the countryside was being siphoned off by foreign compradors or landed elites for luxury consumption. It has also, to some extent, allowed a more humanistic and civilizationally progressive pattern of investment and development in places like China, which are taking seriously the impact of investments on human development and the integrity of the ecosystem. But nationalization and centralized planning have also been used in places like the Soviet Union primarily to support rapid industrialization in order to support a larger military establishment.

This means that we need to devote ourselves to understanding just how the commodification of labor power is best overcome and what that looks like economically at the structural level. To begin with it most likely means redistribution which increases the leverage of workers vis a vis employers, and reduces the pressure to sell their labor power in order to survive. But we cannot assume that we can redistribute our way out of capitalism any more than we can nationalize our way out of it. Much of the wealth in our society represents not so much authentic value as claims on surplus which have been inflated by the way capital markets are working. And so we cannot rely on money taxed away from billionaires, for example, to have the same value once redistributed —or even invested in a more socially productive way— as it did concentrated in the hands of an oligarch. This does not mean that we shouldn’t tax it away. At this point simply reducing their power would improve the situation for humanity. But we need a clear understanding of where the economy as a whole stands at the level of value as well as at the level of price.

The starting point with racism and gender oppression is similar. Just as a rising guaranteed basic income will reduce the pressure on workers to sell their labor power in order to survive, increasing their negotiating power with employers, until the latter have to make work authentically fulfilling, supporting women and members of historically oppressed communities in building real power will force structural change, because once these groups become authentically powerful, structures will need to adapt around them. Racist and mysogynist acts will no longer simply be tolerated and men and colonizing peoples will have to adapt to the new reality, which will favor those who are committed to learning to be relational and generative.

This said, we are where we for a reason, and people have been formed by millennia of exploitation, oppression, and alienation. And so we have to help each other get to the point where we actually do seek to be creative and relational and generative in the context of lives of freely discerned meaning. This (and not maximalist demands or disruptive factional politics in the electoral arena) is the authentic vocation of the Left, and it is why Antonio Gramsci, in elaborating his theory of hegemony, chose the Catholic Church, rather than any historic political party, Communist or otherwise, as his model. We need institutions (and it doesn’t have to be just one) which can help form people morally and intellectually in a way which helps us overcome the scars of those millennia of exploitation, oppression, and alienation and which cultivates free human beings and engaged citizens with a mature spirituality, even as we not only tolerate but encourage different understandings of what this means. And we need institutions, not movements. That is the great lesson of the Cultural Revolution, which attempted to remake Chinese humanity overnight through a combination of denunciations and “study and struggle” sessions which pressured millions into acting contrary to their conscience, ultimately breaking them and nearly destroying  Chinese Civilization. Instead we need teachers, community builders, and spiritual directors who devote their entire lives to building relationships with people in a particular community, understanding who they are and what they want to accomplish in life, what they bring to the table, and where they are broken and scarred, and help them grow intellectually, relationally, and spiritually along which ever path they choose —which means we need both people who take responsibility for the overall spiritual care of communities, and people who can guide others along particular ways. This is what we mean by deep organizing and it is what will carry us beyond simply recovering from Fascism into a more profound structural and civilizational transformation.


The next two years will be critical as we work to consolidate the political gains of November 3 and bring to the fruition the work of thousands of organizers across the country, but especially the Deep South, Texas, and farm country. But so too will the next two decades –and the next two centuries– as humanity faces the existential threats of climate change and artificial intelligence and as we decide whether or not we will remain instruments for the accumulation of Capital, filled with hate towards women and towards the colonized people who do most of our work, or will instead turn again towards the Power of Being as Such, and find it in ourselves and each other to mend the torn fabric of our ecosystem, of our civilization, and of the universe and become the authentic participants in creation which we have the capacity to be.

This entry was posted in Political Theological Analysis and tagged , , , . Bookmark the permalink.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *